PDA

View Full Version : I believe in evo somewhat but geico commercials need to stop



SoulReaverKAIN
Aug 28th, 2007, 7:38 PM
it's a freakin insult when infact they became extinct which prooves we didn't come from them

Sammy56
Aug 28th, 2007, 7:39 PM
I didn't realize those commercials were implying that we did come from Neanderthals. They are just supposed to be funny and different.

Blu-ray
Aug 28th, 2007, 7:43 PM
They are making a play that their website is easy to use. It's not implying that we all evolved from them.

Harry61
Aug 28th, 2007, 7:52 PM
Good grief,

It wasn't intended for evolution bashers. It is designed to grab your attention which it did.

"so easy a cave man can do it"

That was funny. What are you going to do when their series starts up? I am sure there will be questions on that.

Cartesiantheater
Aug 29th, 2007, 1:17 PM
it's a freakin insult when infact they became extinct which prooves we didn't come from them

No it does not. Do you even understand evolution? It is logically possible that we are DESCENDED from them, and then THEIR line died out. We know that birds very likely evolved from dinosaurs, but dinosaurs are extict. This absolutely does NOT prove that birds did not descend from them.

Of course, other evidence suggests that Neanderthal and homo sapiens sapiens came from the same ancestor rather than one from the other.

But regardless of which specific line of descendence we are talking about, homo sapien sapiens certainly came from an anscetrial creature similar to the steriotypical "caveman." All the way to a common anscester of the great apes of today (note that I did NOT say we evolved from the great apes of today).



But in anycase, why the hell is it an insult to use those camercials? You don't have to accept evolution to understand the camercials without being offended. Now, if they had camercials that said "so easy a chimp could do it" would you be offended?

However, what's the difference? Both Neanderthal and the Chimpanzee are creatures that we did NOT descend from, but both descended from the same creature we did. So, if one offends you, so should the other. Just a thought...



(of course, you may not actually accept the theory of evolution- but the camercials don't even explicitly support evolution. They are fiction. The characters are not real... eat the hey and leave the sticks, as they say...)

EDIT- on the other hand, you MIGHT be saying that the camercials are BASHING evolution, and in that case I have completely misunderstood your post. But either way, I can't really see any reason for anyone to be offended... unless they happen to be a caveman...

SoulReaverKAIN
Aug 30th, 2007, 1:10 PM
I agree with what you said descending from dinosaurs, etc is true
but I dont believe they evolved magically like morphing if thats what people
mean when the say evo

DontBeAfraid
Aug 30th, 2007, 2:16 PM
I agree with what you said descending from dinosaurs, etc is true
but I dont believe they evolved magically like morphing if thats what people
mean when the say evoNobody who understands evolution would ever describe it as magical.